The Fault In Our Stars by John Green
pages 1-114
This novel is fairly depressing. The protagonist is witty and likable, which makes her condition more tragic, as a reader. Hazel's cancer casts an ominous shadow over this story. Unlike Romeo & Juliet, her "ill-fated love" is not doomed by quarrels and misunderstandings, but by sickness. She views herself as a tragic figure, and she does not want to "spread" her tragedy by befriending others, or by falling in love. Hazel says, "I'm a grenade and at some point I'm going to blow up and I would like to minimize the casualties...". Her lifeview is scarred by her state, rendering her unwilling to enjoy her remaining days
However, despite her initial inclination, she finds herself falling in love. While I first disliked Augustus Waters, his presence helps Hazel overcome her pessimistic disposition, if only temporarily.
I agree that the novel is fairly sad, but I think that is appropriate to the subject matter. I like your analysis of Hazel's character, particularly where you point out that her worldview is skewed by her circumstances. I am curious to hear what you thought of Green's treatment of "the cancer patient"- I found it somewhat refreshing that he didn't stick to the traditional motivational tale.
ReplyDeleteSo you FEEL depressed, but I am still curious as to whether or not you think the novel worthy of reading? Isn't that a literacy conundrum you face at times? There are many novels I suffer through becuase they are worthy of being read, but I don't like how I feel reading them--hmmm. Would you teach this book
ReplyDeleteI'm going to be honest when I say I got emotional reading the "grenade" quote, partially because of my friend's experience when her fiance died young-- he happened to be my best friend.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, although you believe this is a depressing read, I feel it is absolutely worth sharing with students. Terminal illness does not mean you are a zombie. You are still alive, GO LIVE. And this can apply to multiple situations in our student's lives. Students seem to lose sight of what is truly "awful" in life and a book like this can show them life isn't so bad as this.