Sunday, October 14, 2012

Reading Journal: Brave New World


What I Read: Brave New World, Chapter 4

Prompt: Describe something you have read before that is similar to what you are now reading.

A text that has obvious similarities to Huxley’s Brave New World is Orwell’s 1984. They are both stories about how oppressive governments can transform society into a dystopic nightmare. I am interested in the ways each author considers the methods in which government can control people. Orwell focuses on how controlling language, and the presence of an omnipresent government-surveillance system, can control thought. There is an uncrossable line between the high-ranking “party members” and the “proles”.  The former are essentially infallible; anything they say becomes true. The proles are forced to engage in “doublethink” (the act of simultaneously accepting two conflicting “facts”). The proles internalize this act and legitimately believe whatever they are told.

While class in 1984 was a major component Orwell’s story, it is tackled differently in Brave New World. Huxley delves more into social engineering – both in terms of maintaining a class system and, quite literally, manufacturing people. Interestingly, in chapter 4, Bernard is paranoid that the higher-ups will hear his discontent. However, unlike 1984, the government does not appear to be ubiquitous. Furthermore, through Huxley’s reliance on social taboos to repulse his audience, it is clear that he is more concerned with the loss of morality. It is interesting to see the way aspects of a dystopia can differ between texts, and how they can serve as different criticisms towards modern society. 

2 comments:

  1. I have often been in discussions of which of these two texts (a) would be more likely to be fully implemented and (b) more closely resembles our society. Whereas 1984 keeps people controlled by pain, BNW does so through pleasure (soma, seeming happiness, etc). I like the point you make about how dystopian works can operate in different ways and comment on different things. I like these novels because they can focus on so many things. Creating an entire alternate society allows the author to question everything in his/her own society.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I debated whether to use BNW or 1984 as a canonical, core text this year with 786--I chose BNW because of its direct applicaiton to issues reflected in our current society--issues of genetic engineering, drug use, technlogy as religion--it amazes me that this text, written in 1938, could be so prophetic--but so much of sci-fi is. I think this connects back to Rosenblatt in that an English teacher cannot avoid ethical issues--

    ReplyDelete