What I Read: The Eleventh Plague by Jeff Hirsch, chapters
1-16
Prompt: How does this selection make you feel and why?
The
Eleventh Plague is interesting , due to the very personal narrative. When I
think about the possibility of mass death caused by weapons of mass
destruction, I tend to depersonalize the effects. Actually seeing an adolescent
trying to navigate through this wasteland is jarring; his narrative is full of
personality, and I find myself relating to him. A particular strategy that
Hirsch uses to ground his narrative in reality is his use of real-world
artifacts/brands. When we see a broken down Starbucks, or a huge volume of Lord
of the Rings in Stephen’s backpack, we are reminded that Hirsch’s work is based
in reality.
I found
myself becoming bored with Stephen’s/his father’s relationship with their
grandfather. Beginning the book with his burial is an interesting hook, but I
don’t feel as though the character is fleshed out enough, even through
anecdotes. On the other hand, when the narrative shifts from Stephen
introspecting about his family to the events in Settler’s landing, I found
myself interested.
It's really interesting to me that you connected with Stephen. One thing my book club talked about yesterday was how we all struggled to connect with him! It feels like he pushes the reader away in the same way he pushes outsiders away. To us, he seemed reluctant to trust others. I totally agree with you, though, about Stephen's grandfather. I feel like the beginning of the book implied a bigger connection back to the grandfather, and it just didn't happen. Any reference back to the grandfather seemed superficial.
ReplyDeleteI am just starting this book at the suggestion of Tiffany, so I can't speak to Stephen's voice yet, but I do think that the author possibly is using the family story as a hook for female readers... not that I'm saying this hook will work, but I often see in YA novels the authors trying to appeal to as wide a variety of readers as possible in order to make money. YA itself is a decent market, but no where near as expansive as adult lit.
ReplyDelete