Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Online Reading Journal #3 - "Sold" by Patricia McCormick



"Sold" by Patricia McCormick, complete text

For employment, Lakshmi enters a “happiness house” – a cruel misnomer. "Sold" provides a disturbing look into the seedy underworld of an Indian prostitution ring. Particularly disturbing is the fact that Lakshmi is only thirteen years old. McCormick is particularly frustrated by the fact that such activity is usually not noticed, or acted against, by others. Note the probable double-meaning in the early lines from Lakshmi, looking down at the streets in captivity:

“Each day, a thousand people pass below my window.
Children on their way to school. Mothers hurrying home
from the market. Rickshaw pullers, vegetable sellers, street
Sweepers and alms-seekers.

Not one looks up…”

 Issues like this should definitely be explored in literature. I can see how novels like "Sold" can promote social awareness (and, perhaps, activism). Though I read through the entire book in a couple hours, I feel that McCormick’s poetry and narration is rich enough to warrant a closer reading.

On a side note, the work is a glimpse into a somewhat unfamiliar culture for me. The cultural element of this work would be a boon in a high school classroom, but I wonder if it would be a good idea to have students associate such atrocities with Indian culture – a culture they likely know little about. McCormick based the book in research, so the events within it are realities for many people in India. However, there is a difficult balance to strike when presenting diverse cultures.

Monday, September 17, 2012

Online Reading Journal #2: "Still Alive" by Ruth Kluger


This one is a bit of a ramble. My latest reading is "Still Alive" by Ruth Kluger. This is a highly reflective memoir on the horrible events and conditions during the Holocaust. Two aspects about this novel that set it apart from previous Holocaust accounts is that it is written from a strongly defined female perspective, and that the author describes her transition from these horrendous events to the present day.

Interestingly, Kluger dedicates much of her work towards detailing her experiences after the war, in America. This serves to show how her past influences her to this day. One passage powerfully demonstrates Kluger's feelings about her experiences as a child in Nazi Germany. In it, a patronizing American relative to Kluger says to her, "You have to erase from your memory everything that happened in Europe. You have to make a new beginning...". The author ruminates, "...you can't throw away your life like old clothing, as if you had another outfit in the closet...".

This passage is particularly powerful to me, because, in addition to succinctly and poignantly explaining Kluger's need to tell her story, it reminds us why we continue to teach our youth about the Holocaust (and other horrible events, for that matter). On a large scale, humanity dons the clothing of our history; if we fail to encounter and learn from it, progress becomes impossible.

Online Reading Journal #1 = "Night" by Elie Wiesel


A reading I completed for Clementi's Gender & Holocaust class is Night by Elie Wiesel. While the manner in which Nazi's butchered many innocent Jewish prisoners is shocking, I found myself focusing more on the manner in which Wiesel suffers a "loss of humanity". Indeed, many prisoners of the camp are faced with the need  to be selfish to survive. This leads to a dissolution of family ties, accurate self-perception, and morality.

The conclusion of the novel is somewhat strange. Wiesel constantly questions the existence of a God. In the foreward of the novel, he claims that his survival is not a miracle, but a product of chance. In the conclusion, he outright states that, despite his experiences, he believes in God. However, this God's role is to provide questions about existence, and not answers. I'm not sure how this would provide any consolence, nor what it means, precisely.

Due to the short length of the book, I found myself instantly categorizing the book as YA literature. I understand that Night is canonical, but this is my first encounter with it. Would I use it in a classroom? I doubt it. It is incredibly grim, and it tackles subject matter that adolescents really shouldn't yet encounter.